Key takeaways
- Compare five seed starting trays and kits with cell counts, domes, self-watering reservoirs and grow lights, plus what each pack includes as listed.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through links in this article, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Our top pick: Burpee Self-Watering Seed Starter Tray, 72 Cells. Runner-up: MIXC Seed Starter Kit with Grow Light, 4 Pack.
A seed starting tray looks simple — a grid of small cells in a plastic tray — but the formats on sale differ more than the product photos suggest. Some are complete kits with a water reservoir, a wicking mat and growing pellets in the box. Some build a small grow light into the humidity dome. Others are plain cell inserts in bulk, meant to drop into a standard flat you already own. The five picks below cover those main formats: a self-watering Burpee kit with pellets included, a lighted MIXC kit of four small trays, a clear five-pack from Bonviee for small batches, a ten-set Gardzen propagator with larger 40-cell trays, and Handy Pantry 72-cell inserts sold as bulk sheets. Every cell count, tray count and component list is quoted as listed by the maker, and each pick is pinned to one specific listing, so check the pack size on the listing before you order — the same tray family is often sold in several counts.
How to Choose a Seed Starting Tray
Match the cell count to the sowing, not the other way round. Small 12-cell trays suit a windowsill batch of herbs or a few tomato plants, and having several small trays lets you move one variety to stronger light without disturbing the rest. A single 72-cell tray covers a whole vegetable plan in one footprint. Bulk inserts with hundreds of cells only make sense if you sow in successions all season. Count the total cells in the pack as listed, and remember that a “10 pack” of 12-cell trays and a “10 pack” of 72-cell sheets are very different purchases.
Decide how the seedlings will get water. Plain trays need watering from above or a separate flat underneath for bottom watering. A self-watering kit adds a reservoir and a capillary mat that draws water up into the cells, which stretches the interval between refills. If you bottom water, look for a watertight base tray in the box; if the listing is for inserts only, you will need to supply the flat yourself.
Treat the dome as a germination tool. A clear humidity dome holds warm, moist air around freshly sown seeds and lifts off once seedlings are up. A vent in the dome lets you open up airflow gradually instead of removing the lid in one step. Taller, elevated domes buy a few extra days before seedlings touch the lid. No dome changes the fact that seedlings need strong light as soon as they emerge, which is why one pick below builds the light into the dome itself.
Check the cell size and how seedlings come out. Cells around 1.5 inches square are the common seed starting size as listed; larger cells hold more mix and give roots longer before transplanting. Thin plug inserts are usually cut or torn into sections and treated as semi-disposable, while thicker reusable trays and kits are washed and kept for the next sowing. Either way, judge a tray by what the listing actually includes — dome, base, labels, pellets — rather than by the sowing scene in the photo.
The 5 Best Seed Starting Trays
1. Burpee Self-Watering Seed Starter Tray, 72 Cells
This is the most complete kit in the group, and the only one that includes the growing medium. Two 36-cell trays sit on plant stands inside a water reservoir tray, with a self-watering mat drawing water up to the cells and 72 coir growing pellets that expand when soaked, so there is no bag of mix to measure out. A clear dome cover and plant markers are in the box as well. The cells are listed at 1.5 by 1.5 by 2 inches, and the whole system follows the standard 10 by 20 inch footprint, so it fits the shelves and light setups most indoor growers already use. Choose it if you want one purchase that covers tray, water and medium for a full tray of seedlings, and you are happy to sow into pellets rather than loose mix.
Specs
- Brand: Burpee
- Format: self-watering kit with reservoir and wicking mat
- Cells: 72 total (two 36-cell trays), as listed
- Cell size: 1.5 x 1.5 x 2 inches, as listed
- Footprint: 10 x 20 inches, as listed
- Included: water reservoir tray, self-watering mat, plant stands, 72 coir growing pellets, dome cover and plant markers, as listed
2. MIXC Seed Starter Kit with Grow Light, 4 Pack
The MIXC kit answers the light problem directly: each of its four small trays carries a humidity dome with 12 full-spectrum LED beads built in, so seedlings get light from directly overhead instead of leaning toward a window. Each tray holds 12 cells of 1.5 by 1.5 by 2 inches as listed, for 48 cells across the pack, and the domes are elevated to give seedlings more headroom before transplanting. The clear cell trays have drainage holes and side grips so the insert lifts out of the watertight base without squeezing the cells, and the maker lists the trays as thicker reusable PVC. Pick this format if your starting spot is a shelf or counter away from a bright window, and you sow in small batches that benefit from separate domes.
Specs
- Brand: MIXC
- Format: grow light kit with elevated domes
- Trays in pack: 4, as listed
- Cells: 12 per tray, 48 total, as listed
- Cell size: 1.5 x 1.5 x 2 inches, as listed
- Light: 12 full-spectrum LED beads per dome, as listed
- Included: 4 cell trays, 4 watertight base trays, 4 humidity domes and 10 plant labels, as listed
3. Bonviee 5-Pack Seed Starter Trays, Clear
Bonviee sells the small-batch format in clear plastic: five 12-cell trays, every part transparent, so you can watch moisture in the mix and check root development through the cell wall without lifting a seedling out. Each tray comes with its own clear base, a humidity vent piece and a clear lid, and the cell trays have drainage holes to keep excess water moving. Sixty cells across the pack is a sensible size for a mixed sowing of herbs, flowers and a few vegetables, and the separate trays make staggered sowing easy — start one tray this week, another when the first is up. Choose it if you start modest quantities, like to see what is happening below the surface, and do not need lights or a reservoir in the box.
Specs
- Brand: Bonviee
- Format: clear cell tray kit with domes and bases
- Trays in pack: 5, as listed
- Cells: 12 per tray, 60 total, as listed
- Cell tray: clear, with drainage holes, as listed
- Included: 5 clear 12-cell trays, 5 clear base trays, 5 humidity vents, 5 clear lids and 10 plant labels, as listed
- Listing pinned: 5 Packs, Clear
4. Gardzen 10-Set Garden Propagator Set, 40-Cell Trays
Gardzen’s propagator set scales the covered-tray format up. Each of the ten sets pairs a 40-cell tray, listed at 15 by 9 inches, with its own vented humidity dome and base, so the pack covers 400 cells while still letting you run each tray as an independent unit with its own sowing date. That layout suits gardeners who start several crops in rotation — one tray of brassicas under its dome while another of peppers is already uncovered and growing on. The domes are vented, so airflow can be opened up per tray as its seedlings emerge. Pick it if a single 72-cell tray is too small but loose bulk inserts are more than you want to manage, and you would rather keep domes and bases matched to every tray.
Specs
- Brand: Gardzen
- Format: propagator set with vented dome and base
- Sets in pack: 10, as listed
- Cells: 40 per tray, 400 total, as listed
- Tray size: 15 x 9 inches, as listed
- Dome: humidity dome with vents, as listed
5. Handy Pantry Seed Tray Inserts, 72 Cells, 10 Sheets
This is the bulk option, and it is inserts only: ten sheets of 72 cells each, 720 cells in the pack, with no domes or base trays included. Each sheet is molded so it can be separated into twelve six-cell sections, which makes it easy to tear off exactly the number of cells a sowing needs and to hand out or move a section without carrying a whole sheet. The maker lists the sheets as BPA-free polystyrene, and the 72-cell layout follows the standard flat format, so the inserts drop into the 1020-style trays and domes sold separately. Choose it if you already own flats and covers, sow heavily through the season, and want the lowest-fuss way to keep fresh cells on hand — just confirm your existing trays match before ordering.
Specs
- Brand: Handy Pantry
- Format: cell insert sheets only (no dome or base included)
- Sheets in pack: 10, as listed
- Cells: 72 per sheet, 720 total, as listed
- Sections: each sheet separates into 12 six-cell sections, as listed
- Material: BPA-free polystyrene, as listed
Quick Comparison
| Pick | Format | Trays in pack | Cells per tray | Total cells | Dome | Extras as listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Burpee Self-Watering | Self-watering kit | 2 | 36 | 72 | Yes, plain cover | Reservoir, wicking mat, 72 coir pellets, markers |
| MIXC Grow Light Kit | Lighted kit | 4 | 12 | 48 | Yes, elevated, with LED light | Watertight bases, plant labels |
| Bonviee 5-Pack Clear | Clear tray kit | 5 | 12 | 60 | Yes, with vent piece | Clear bases and lids, plant labels |
| Gardzen Propagator Set | Propagator set | 10 | 40 | 400 | Yes, vented | Base tray with each set |
| Handy Pantry Inserts | Insert sheets | 10 sheets | 72 | 720 | No | Separates into six-cell sections |
FAQ
How many cells do I actually need?
Work backwards from the garden: count the plants you intend to set out, then add spare cells for seeds that fail and seedlings you discard. For most home vegetable gardens that lands between 48 and 120 cells, which is why both small multi-tray packs and single 72-cell kits exist. Buy the format that matches your sowing pattern rather than the largest count.
Do I need a humidity dome?
A dome helps most in the first days, while seeds are still below the surface and the mix must stay evenly moist. Once seedlings emerge, the dome should be vented or removed so air moves and stems grow stocky. A vented or elevated dome simply gives you more control over that transition; it is not a requirement for starting seeds.
Are pellets or loose mix better in these trays?
Pellets, like the coir pellets in the Burpee kit, keep sowing tidy and portion the medium for you, but they tie you to buying refills in the same size. Loose seed starting mix works in any cell tray or insert and lets you fill cells to your own depth. The tray choice matters more than the medium: match the cell size to how long seedlings will stay in it.
Can these trays be reused?
The thicker kit trays — the Burpee, MIXC, Bonviee and Gardzen sets — are built to be washed and used again for multiple sowings. Thin insert sheets like the Handy Pantry pack are lighter moldings; many growers get more than one sowing from them, but they are the part of the setup most often replaced. Wash any reused tray before refilling it.
Do I still need a heat mat or separate light?
None of these five picks includes a heat mat, and only the MIXC kit includes a light. Bottom heat is a separate purchase if your starting room runs cold, and any tray other than the lighted kit needs a bright window or a separate grow light once seedlings are up. Plan the light first — it is the input seedlings miss most indoors.
Conclusion
Start with the format, not the brand. If watering is your weak point, the Burpee self-watering kit covers tray, reservoir and pellets in one box. If light is the weak point, the MIXC kit builds it into the dome. Small, staggered sowings suit the clear Bonviee five-pack, larger rotations suit the Gardzen propagator sets, and growers who already own flats should look at the Handy Pantry inserts for sheer cell count. Whichever you choose, confirm the tray count and cell count on the listing itself, since every family here is sold in more than one pack size.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeA free business account with business pricing and bulk-buying tools for work, shop or home office.
Create a business accountAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!