Key takeaways
- Compare the best pie plates and pie dishes for home bakers: glass, ceramic, stoneware and nonstick metal picks with sizes, oven limits and care details.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through links in this article, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Our top pick: Pyrex Bakeware 9.5-Inch Scalloped Glass Pie Plate (2-Pack). Runner-up: OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid.
A pie plate looks like the simplest pan in the kitchen — a shallow round dish with sloped sides — but the material it is made from quietly decides how your crust bakes. Glass lets you watch the bottom brown, ceramic and stoneware hold heat for serving, and metal heats fast for crisp edges. Depth matters just as much: a standard plate handles single-crust pies, while a deeper dish is what double-crust and slab-style fillings actually need.
This guide compares five well-regarded pie plates and dishes across glass, ceramic, stoneware, and metal, all in the standard 9 to 9.5 inch range that most recipes assume. Every pick is a real product with specs taken from its listing, so you can match diameter, depth, oven limit, and cleanup style to the pies you bake most.
How to Choose a Pie Plate or Pie Dish
Material. Glass conducts heat slowly and evenly, and because it is transparent you can check the underside of the crust without guesswork. Ceramic and stoneware also bake gently and retain heat well, so a pie stays warm at the table, and their glazed finishes go straight from oven to serving. Metal heats the fastest and tends to produce the crispest bottom crust, but it offers no view of browning and thin pans can warp.
Diameter and depth. Most American pie recipes are written for a 9 inch plate. A 9.5 inch plate works too, though very full fillings sit a little lower. Depth is the bigger decision: around 1.25 to 1.5 inches suits custard, pumpkin, and other single-crust pies, while roughly 2 inches or more gives double-crust fruit pies room for filling and a top crust without spillover.
Oven limit and temperature changes. Pie bakes happen between about 325°F and 450°F, so check that the dish covers that range with margin. If you assemble pies ahead and freeze them, look for a dish listed as freezer safe — and for glass, borosilicate handles the move from freezer to a hot oven better than ordinary glass. Broiler safety only matters if you finish meringue or crumb toppings under high heat.
Care and storage. Glass, ceramic, and stoneware picks here are mostly dishwasher safe; coated metal usually asks for hand washing to protect its nonstick surface. In a minimalist kitchen, one versatile plate that bakes, serves, and stores leftovers beats a stack of single-purpose pans, so extras like a storage lid are worth weighing.
The 5 Best Pie Plates and Pie Dishes
1. Pyrex Bakeware 9.5-Inch Scalloped Glass Pie Plate (2-Pack) — the clear classic, doubled
Pyrex is the name most home bakers start with, and this two-pack of its 9.5 inch scalloped plate is the straightforward glass option. The clear, non-porous glass will not absorb odors or stains, lets you watch the bottom crust turn golden, and the scalloped rim gives a decorative edge to crimp against and a prettier serving presentation. Getting two plates in the box is quietly practical: one pie can cool or chill while the second bakes, which is exactly how holiday baking days actually go. The plates are listed as oven, microwave, and dishwasher safe, and they are made in the USA. If you want one dependable glass plate shape and a spare for busy baking days, this is the default buy.
Specs:
– Brand: Pyrex
– Diameter: 9.5 in, scalloped rim
– Depth: Not stated separately on the listing
– Material: Glass, non-porous
– Set size: 2 plates
– Oven limit: Listed as oven safe; no numeric limit stated on the listing
– Freezer safe: Not stated on the listing
– Broiler safe: Not stated on the listing
– Dishwasher safe: Yes
– Microwave safe: Yes
– Model: 1105393
– ASIN: B01253RYDA
2. OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid — borosilicate that stores and travels
The OXO plate solves the two awkward moments in pie baking: moving a hot dish and storing what is left. It is made from borosilicate glass, which the maker positions for extreme temperature changes, so the plate can go from freezer or fridge into the oven or microwave without cracking. A generous rim gives you a secure grip with oven mitts, and the included BPA-free plastic lid snaps on for fridge storage and spill-resistant transport — the lid is for storage only and stays out of the oven. At 9 inches across and about 2 inches deep with a 1.4 quart capacity, it suits most standard recipes, including moderately filled double-crust pies. It is the strongest pick here for bakers who carry pies to gatherings.
Specs:
– Brand: OXO
– Diameter: 9 in
– Depth: 2 in
– Material: Borosilicate glass
– Capacity: 1.4 qt
– Oven limit: 450°F as stated by the maker
– Freezer safe: Yes — listed for freezer-to-oven use
– Broiler safe: No
– Dishwasher safe: Yes
– Extras: BPA-free plastic lid for storage and transport (not oven safe)
– Model: 11249100
– ASIN: B07PQH8ZTX
3. Emile Henry Modern Classics 9-Inch Pie Dish — the deep ceramic pick
Emile Henry has made ceramic bakeware in Burgundy, France since 1850, and its Modern Classics pie dish is the deep option in this lineup: the listed dimensions run about 2.56 inches tall, with a 1.4 quart capacity for generous double-crust fillings. The HR (high resistance) ceramic is made from high-fired Burgundy clay that diffuses heat gently and evenly, and the listing states it can go directly from the freezer into a hot oven. The upper temperature is listed at 520°F, and the dish is also listed as broiler and microwave safe, with a hard glaze that resists scratches. In the Sugar white finish it moves from oven to table without a second serving dish. Choose it if you bake deep fruit pies and want one handsome dish for baking and serving.
Specs:
– Brand: Emile Henry
– Diameter: 9 in
– Depth: 2.56 in (listed product dimensions 9 x 9 x 2.56 in)
– Material: HR ceramic (high-fired Burgundy clay)
– Capacity: 1.4 qt
– Oven limit: 520°F as listed
– Freezer safe: Yes — listed for freezer-to-oven use
– Broiler safe: Yes
– Dishwasher safe: Yes
– Microwave safe: Yes
– Model: 236121
– ASIN: B00WRIJ306
4. Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Pie Dish, 9-Inch — stoneware that keeps pie warm
Le Creuset’s Heritage dish brings the brand’s stoneware to a classic pie shape, with a scalloped edge that helps you form a decorative crust and angled side walls that make serving neat slices easier. The dense stoneware distributes heat evenly for uniform browning and holds that heat at the table, so second slices stay warm. The colorful glaze — this listing is the Cerise red finish — is described as nonporous, scratch resistant, and virtually nonstick for easier cleanup. The listing gives an upper temperature of 500°F and lists the dish as freezer, microwave, and dishwasher safe. It is the pick for bakers who serve pie in the dish it baked in and want the dish itself to look like part of the occasion.
Specs:
– Brand: Le Creuset
– Diameter: 9 in
– Dimensions: 10.2 x 10.2 x 2.2 in
– Material: Stoneware with colored glaze
– Oven limit: 500°F as listed
– Freezer safe: Yes
– Broiler safe: Not stated on the listing
– Dishwasher safe: Yes
– Microwave safe: Yes
– Model: PG1955-2367
– ASIN: B0BH9F3SVN
5. USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, 9-Inch — fast-heating metal with easy release
For bakers who chase a crisp bottom crust, metal is the traditional answer, and USA Pan’s 9 inch pie pan is the commercial-style version. It is made from heavy gauge aluminized steel with a corrugated surface that increases air circulation and reduces contact between pan and crust, which helps both browning and release. The Americoat silicone nonstick coating is listed as PTFE-, PFOA-, and BPA-free, and the baking surface measures a full 9 by 1.5 inches — right for standard single-crust pies and sturdy enough for double-crust ones. The listed oven limit is 450°F, and the pan is made in the USA. The trade-off is care: the listing specifies hand washing and marks the pan as not dishwasher safe, the usual price of keeping a nonstick coating slick for years.
Specs:
– Brand: USA Pan
– Diameter: 9 in baking surface
– Depth: 1.5 in
– Material: Aluminized steel with Americoat silicone nonstick coating
– Oven limit: 450°F as listed
– Freezer safe: Yes, as listed
– Broiler safe: Not stated on the listing
– Dishwasher safe: No — hand wash as specified
– Model: 1100PE
– ASIN: B002UNMZNU
Quick Comparison
| Pick | Material | Size | Depth | Oven limit | Dishwasher safe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pyrex Scalloped (2-Pack) | Glass | 9.5 in | Not stated on listing | Oven safe, no numeric limit stated | Yes |
| OXO Good Grips with Lid | Borosilicate glass | 9 in | 2 in | 450°F | Yes |
| Emile Henry Modern Classics | HR ceramic | 9 in | 2.56 in | 520°F | Yes |
| Le Creuset Heritage | Stoneware | 9 in | 2.2 in overall height | 500°F | Yes |
| USA Pan Pie Pan | Aluminized steel, nonstick | 9 in | 1.5 in | 450°F | No — hand wash |
FAQ
What size pie plate do most recipes need?
A 9 inch plate is the standard most recipes assume. A 9.5 inch plate like the Pyrex pick also works; deep or very full fillings simply sit slightly lower. Match depth to the recipe as well — a deep dish changes how a standard filling fills the crust.
Which material gives the crispiest bottom crust?
Metal heats fastest, so a steel pan like the USA Pan pick is the usual choice for a crisp base. Glass bakes more gently but lets you see the bottom browning, which many bakers find more useful than speed. Ceramic and stoneware sit between the two and keep the finished pie warmer for serving.
Can I bake a frozen pie in a glass plate?
Only if the plate is listed for it. Borosilicate glass, like the OXO pick, is made for freezer-to-oven temperature changes. With ordinary glass or ceramic not listed as freezer safe, let the dish warm up gradually and always put it into a preheated oven on a room-temperature surface.
Do I need a deep pie dish?
If you mostly bake pumpkin, custard, or other single-crust pies, a standard depth around 1.5 inches is enough. If double-crust fruit pies are your regular bake, a deeper dish around 2 inches or more — the Emile Henry or OXO picks here — keeps filling and top crust contained.
How do I stop slices from sticking?
A light coating of butter or baking spray helps in glass and ceramic, and nonstick metal releases most easily of all. Letting the pie cool fully before slicing makes the biggest difference, since fillings set as they cool and the crust firms up.
Conclusion
For most home bakers, a clear glass plate is the calm, versatile default: the Pyrex two-pack covers everyday baking with a spare for busy days, and the OXO adds borosilicate freezer-to-oven confidence plus a lid for storage and travel. If you bake deep double-crust pies and serve them in the dish, the Emile Henry ceramic and Le Creuset stoneware picks earn their place, while the USA Pan steel pan is the one to reach for when a crisp bottom crust is the whole point. Pick by the pies you actually bake, and one good dish will cover nearly all of them.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeA free business account with business pricing and bulk-buying tools for work, shop or home office.
Create a business accountAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!